Comments on “Spam from God”

Add new comment

Great stuff!

Robert Ellis 2011-01-24

I like this comparison very much!

merry atheism

Kate Gowen 2011-01-24

We could break out in a chorus of LOL! Atheism with some wit about it makes its point much more convincingly than the likes of Chris Hitchens and Richard Dawkins.

Brilliant. I am going to

Sabio 2011-01-25

Brilliant. I am going to spend a bit of time seeing if I can get some blogging atheists to see this post. Nicely done.

@ Kate:
concerning “the likes of Chris Hitchens and Richards Dawkins”: I think their voices may have ironically allow those with more measure to find ears. And I don’t think anyone could accuse Dawkins and certainly not Hitchens of lacking in wit. Many outspoken, bold, caustive atheists have made a safer playground for nontheists & non-eternalists to exercise their less exaggerated and more constrained voices.
[Hope I am reading your right]


David Chapman 2011-01-25

@Sabio Thank you very much!

I’ll have quite a lot more to say about atheism in this book. It will be from an unusual perspective, though. I take atheism for granted, and won’t be making any arguments in favor of it. (I am in favor of it, but lots of other people are doing good work on that, including of course yourself.)

Rather, I look at atheism as a special case of the rejection of eternalism. There are non-theistic eternalisms, which are dangerous and wrong in some of the same ways as theistic religions, and in some other ways as well. I hope to make more people aware of these dangers. Atheists are, naturally, particularly likely to be receptive.

This page (“Spam from God”) is fun, I hope, and perhaps a little offensive in a helpful way. I hope some atheists will enjoy it. It’s not meant as an argument for atheism, though. I wrote it actually as a preface to the next page (“Wavering nihilism: emotional dynamics”).

These emotional dynamics are ones that atheists can fall into. Atheism is not necessarily nihilist, but unless you have a clear understanding of the third alternative to eternalism and nihilism, the nihilist errors are ones atheists are more likely to make.

Pitfalls for Atheists Abound !

Sabio 2011-01-25

I am afraid we will probably agree – how boring. :-)

Eternalism may look like a

Ricardo Brito 2011-06-10

Eternalism may look like a scam. Nihilism too. But maybe we are eternal. That may be wishfull thinking, but why can’t something exist somehow just because we wish it to be that same way, or just because it’s confortable for us? Maybe it’s a good coincidence, i’m sure there are other’s that are not that good. The fact that there is a better option, that causes less suffering doesn’t mean that the first ones are fake, or inexistent. Does it? And why should we opt for less suffering?

Thank You

what gets taken for granted

Mike Jones 2023-11-24

You also take the hegemony of English for granted. When are you going to learn Esperanto?

Add new comment:

You can use some Markdown and/or HTML formatting here.

Optional, but required if you want follow-up notifications. Used to show your Gravatar if you have one. Address will not be shown publicly.

If you check this box, you will get an email whenever there’s a new comment on this page. The emails include a link to unsubscribe.